, SecurityFocus 2005-02-09
In the first case of its kind, a California video game maker is suing an entire community of software tinkerers for reverse engineering and modifying Xbox games that they legally purchased.
Expand all |
Post comment
Theory of moral rights
2005-02-10
Doug Sibley (15 replies)
Doug Sibley (15 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
2005-02-10
Alterac (Alterac (at) McDonaldConsulting (dot) com [email concealed]) (2 replies)
Alterac (Alterac (at) McDonaldConsulting (dot) com [email concealed]) (2 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
2005-02-18
D'Glenn (dglenn (at) radix (dot) net [email concealed])
D'Glenn (dglenn (at) radix (dot) net [email concealed])
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
2005-02-10
Rich (2 replies)
Rich (2 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
2005-02-14
Michael (at) UltraPresence (dot) net [email concealed]
Michael (at) UltraPresence (dot) net [email concealed]
"We spent millions of dollars to develop these games, and people are coming in and changing the code to their liking, and that's illegal."
2005-02-11
tiger YAMATO
tiger YAMATO
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
2005-02-11
Tanis (1 replies)
Tanis (1 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
2005-02-15
Anonymous (1 replies)
Anonymous (1 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
2005-02-18
D'Glenn (dglenn (at) radix (dot) net [email concealed])
D'Glenn (dglenn (at) radix (dot) net [email concealed])
They Are Killing Their Own Best Customers: What Kind of Game Is DoA Beach Volleyball
2005-02-11
Anonymous
Anonymous

Let's look at this issue imparcially:
- The user has the right to use the software as he pleases, as long it's for his personal use. That includes modding, in my view. He can even burn the media, or use it for target practice, as a previous poster mentioned. It's the user's prerrogative.
- Now, the company can consider that some modding can be prejudicial to company image, like associating nudity or any offensive image, to its products. In that case, the company can decide it can take legal action.
But in this case, the game could already be considered controversial, and if I remember right, it was when one of these games was launched, so that last point doesn't apply and it has no case.
Looking in other perspective, the company is shunning its user base. It is attacking its customers. That's a stupid move.
[ reply ]
Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/articles/10466/30544#30544