Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games
Kevin Poulsen, SecurityFocus 2005-02-09

In the first case of its kind, a California video game maker is suing an entire community of software tinkerers for reverse engineering and modifying Xbox games that they legally purchased.

Comments Mode:
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-10
Doug Sibley (15 replies)
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-10
Anonymous (2 replies)
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-10
Anonymous
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-10
Anonymous
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-10
Mark A. (1 replies)
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-11
crippled ninja
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-10
Anonymous
moral rights, not in the USA 2005-02-11
Anonymous
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-11
Anonymous
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-11
Clint
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-11
Anonymous
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-11
Silverfish
Moral Rights indeed. 2005-02-11
Anonymous
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-11
Anonymous
Ok, you say that tecmo is in the right because an author can sue a publisher for mistakes? That's stupid, that's an issue between creator and production, the customer isn't involved in that situation! The author can't sue me because I post on the internet "the ending would be better like this: ..." because I am referncing his work and not claiming it as my own. So if whoever actually make's the millions of copies of the game screws up the print in the manual, or stamps defective disks, your aguement there would hold water. But what would that have to do with custom skinning?

You need to learn what a comparison is. A statue, a SINGLE statue, with no info about who owns it compared to a mass produced game.

It is my right to mod a game for my personal use. From what I have read, these people have done nothing to claim they wrote any original code, and are not trying to sell anything. Given that, what's morally wrong about it? You have to BUY the game to mod it.

So do you think Id Software should sue me because I installed a mod that attaches a flashlight to my handgun in Doom3? See, thats an applicable comparison.

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/articles/10466/30569#30569
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-12
GXCori
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-12
Anonymous
Theory of moral rights 2005-02-15
Anonymous (2 replies)
Reality of moral rights 2005-02-16
Anonymous
Re: Theory of moral rights 2006-03-09
Doug Sibley
Re: Theory of moral rights 2006-03-22
Anonymous
Re: B. S. 2009-06-15
Anonymous
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-10
Former Ninjahacker member
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-10
Alterac (Alterac (at) McDonaldConsulting (dot) com [email concealed]) (2 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-18
D'Glenn (dglenn (at) radix (dot) net [email concealed])
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-10
Rich (2 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-14
Michael (at) UltraPresence (dot) net [email concealed]
In other news... 2005-02-10
Anonymous (1 replies)
In other news... 2005-02-11
Kylratix
lets list some current games: 2005-02-10
Anonymous (1 replies)
lets list some current games: 2005-02-14
Christ, Jesus H.
Nipples = lawsuit 2005-02-11
Anonymous
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-11
Tanis (1 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-15
Anonymous (1 replies)
Hackers sued for tinkering with Xbox games 2005-02-18
D'Glenn (dglenn (at) radix (dot) net [email concealed])
Boycott 2005-02-11
Anonymous
Where is the outrage?! 2005-02-14
Pimpdad
Tecmo - you just lost a paying customer! 2005-02-14
Ex-Tecmo PAYING Customer!!!!!
Lawsuit Heaven 2005-02-15
Orcusb
Legal situation in Germany 2005-02-16
Anonymous
We can help 2005-02-16
Larry
This is going too far!!! 2005-02-16
aaron.shuford (at) wku (dot) edu [email concealed]







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus