Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Microsoft: Closed source is more secure
Kevin Poulsen, SecurityFocus 2001-04-12

Redmond's security response chief warns the RSA Conference of the perils of open source.

Comments Mode:
Security under MS products VS. Linux, *BSD 2001-04-12
giard.pascal (at) teccart.qc (dot) ca [email concealed]
Now I know 2001-04-12
Anonymous
Crock of sh*t... 2001-04-12
Jim Powers
wow, that's a lot of spin 2001-04-13
wiggum
OpenBSD 2001-04-13
Carl Thomas
MS - Lipner Comments 2001-04-13
Nilanjan Chaks
opensource less secure? 2001-04-13
osiris
Microsoft should get a clue. 2001-04-13
Reaperx1
He's low on credibility 2001-04-13
Ajay Shah
Wha?? 2001-04-13
bleezer (at) plz (dot) com [email concealed]
FUD 2001-04-13
x3co
Closed source more secure? Really? 2001-04-13
counter_counterinsurgency (at) nospam.hotmail (dot) com [email concealed]
Is Microsoft code more secure than open alternatives? 2001-04-13
Larry Fahnoe <fahnoe (at) FahnoeTech (dot) com [email concealed]>
Open Souce security 2001-04-13
Charles E. Hill
Microsoft: Closed source is more secure FSVO secure 2001-04-13
Shmuel (Seymour J.) Metz <shmuel (at) acm (dot) org [email concealed]> (2 replies)
Closed source burdened by "boring, expensive" QA 2001-04-16
counter_counterinsurgency (at) nospam.hotmail (dot) com [email concealed]
Microsoft: Closed source is more secure FSVO secure 2001-04-17
bassethound2 (at) yahoo (dot) com [email concealed]
Going through the motions != Security 2001-04-13
topeka (at) catchen (dot) org [email concealed]
Closed source software is secure 2001-04-13
soumyac (at) bigfoot (dot) com [email concealed]
An observation 2001-04-13
Harry G
Which explains why... 2001-04-13
Con Zymaris, CEO Cybersource Pty. Ltd. Australia
nobody buys ms argument 2001-04-16
j lock <jlock (at) compooter (dot) net [email concealed]>
Open vs. closed not necessarily it.... 2001-04-16
abostaph (at) usa (dot) net [email concealed] (1 replies)
Open vs. closed not necessarily it.... 2001-04-16
Microsoft Defender (2 replies)
Open vs. closed not necessarily it.... 2001-04-18
abostaph (at) usa (dot) net [email concealed] (1 replies)
Open vs. closed not necessarily it.... 2001-04-18
M$ Defender
I have to say I am impressed by the civility of the replies - kudos for not ranting and then TYPING THINGS IN ALL CAPS.

Yes, M$ does not have the greatest track record in security - however, from a logical business standpoint, Microsoft has the most to gain and the least to lose by producing secure products. Eventually, they will figure this out. Also, try not to assume all M$ customers are "sheep" - there are legitimate reasons for working with Microsoft products besides being "duped."

I have developed and used software on both sides of the aisle and there is no vendor that I am aware of that has produced 100% secure software. Being the most popular means more people are affected by your bugs and thus gives everyone the impression that you are one with the most problems. This is not always true. Like most things in life - its a matter of perspective. I am currently programming in .NET and let me tell you know - M$ is getting VERY serious about security. Give them time - trust in the free enterprise system, and if you still don't like M$ - don't buy it. No one is forcing you.

Would you feel better if Sun had M$'s market share? Oracle? Someone has to be #1 - be happy its someone already under scrutiny. The enemy you know is better than the enemy you don't every time....

Forgive MY ranting. My keyboard runneth over....

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/articles/191/5334#5334
I hope Mr Lipner reads this 2001-04-17
dirge
Security Vulnerability Open Source vs Closed Source 2001-04-17
Rod <snaketails (at) optushome.com (dot) au [email concealed]>
who gets cracked more? 2001-04-18
TauRine (1 replies)
who gets cracked more? 2001-04-18
M$ Defender (3 replies)
who gets cracked more? 2001-04-18
brian (1 replies)
who gets cracked more? 2001-04-18
M$ Defender
who gets cracked more? 2001-04-18
dirge
who gets cracked more? 2001-04-19
Bruce Garlock
His arguments contradict each other! 2001-04-19
nobody important







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus