, SecurityFocus 2004-03-18
A pair of coders nurturing a deep antipathy for software pirates set off a controversy Thursday when they went public with a months-old experiment to trick file sharers into running a Trojan horse program that chastises users and reports back to a central server.
Expand all |
Post comment
Good for them
2004-03-19
nosebreaker.com (1 replies)
nosebreaker.com (1 replies)
Good for them? - Questionable Ethics
2004-03-20
Anonymous (4 replies)
Anonymous (4 replies)
Questionable Ethics? it's everywhere
2004-03-20
Anonymous (1 replies)
Anonymous (1 replies)
You all might think it's all fun and games..............
2004-03-20
neb (3 replies)
neb (3 replies)
You all might think it's all fun and games..............
2004-03-21
Anonymous (1 replies)
Anonymous (1 replies)
Don't blame real virus coders cause if you have real copies of Windows then you are fully patched!
2004-03-21
Geist (4 replies)
Geist (4 replies)
blame real virus coders cause if you have real copies of Windows then you are still not fully patched!
2004-03-21
Anonymous
Anonymous
Don't blame real virus coders cause if you have real copies of Windows then you are fully patched!
2004-03-22
Anonymous
Anonymous
We like to call that "Entrapment" in the legal world
2004-03-22
Reuben (4 replies)
Reuben (4 replies)

One presumes that before the 'Bad Pirate' warning message, some sort of license agreement is displayed? Does the user have to agree to this?
If not, the law is being broken and privacy invaded. No-one has any right to install software on someone else's PC unless they have agreed to the installation.
One assumes they have registered with the Data Protection Registrar or the equivalent in their country as they are storing personal information about 'users' on a central server? If not a server under there control, does the company who owns the server have the necessary registration? Again, if not then potentially the law is being broken.
Perhaps a bounty will be issued for Mr. Griffin and friends subsequent arrest and conviction?
And by the way, why are they themselves using file sharing software anyway? I think it highly unlikely they are only using it for legitimate file swapping. Have they ever swapped any copyrighted music files?!
The word 'hypocrisy' springs to mind!
[ reply ]
Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/articles/8279/25427#25427