This is a two-sided case. Should people pirate software? No. Should your private information (IP address and the like) be recorded and on public display? No. I think this project would have served its purpose if they only posted how many times it was executed and the time spent open after said execution.

As far as laws being broken, who really cares? They aren't causing any harm, except in the way of posting the IP information for each user. If they only gathered anonymous statistics about the programs usage, this would be OK in my book.

I don't think anyone really pays attention to those EUA, so even if one was included, I don't think that would really make a difference. Personally, anything downloaded off of a file sharing network should be examined for virii and your firewall should be up to prevent information from being sent over your network connection. If the file was clean, which only means it is not a wide-spread virus, then you could still run the program with minimal risk while keeping your privacy since your firewall would have detected its attempts to communicate to the outside world.

The bigger question here is, "Why weren't the users running a firewall that monitored both incoming and outgoing traffic?"

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/articles/8279/25437#25437