Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
One Patch to Rule Them All
Tim Mullen, 2002-09-30

A recent XP security hole begs the question, do we really want Microsoft to release individual fixes for every bug?

Comments Mode:
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-09-30
Anonymous (1 replies)
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-08
Anonymous
Security patchs are diffrent 2002-09-30
Anonymous
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-01
Anonymous (1 replies)
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-02
Anonymous
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-01
Anonymous
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-01
Anonymous
RE: One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-01
Piroufreek
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-01
Anonymous (1 replies)
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-04
Anonymous
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-01
Anonymous
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-01
Todd Knarr
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-02
security@NOdsia.SPAM.com
>The fact is, the best way to provide ultimate update >levels for the client is with a complete service pack.
This is not fact, it's opinion.

>It isn't a perfect system, but the service pack paradigm
>the best we've got.
I work with a number of OSes, most notably nix (AIX, and Linux Redhat) in addition to W2K.

The smaller patch systems for nix provides for a number of advantages:
1. Easier to fix a specific problem
2. Easier to perform testing and evaluation
3. Quicker to download.
4. Less likely to create a bigger problem.

Naturally these myriad patches can and are bundled similar to the MS Service Pack, so the user has the choice.

The disadvantages of the Tolkien-esque MS approach are blinding, and serve only to remind us that MS continues to treat security as a PR issue. "quick bury the problem, they won't notice".

That said, MS do understand the concept of small patches as anyone who's spend many a happy hour on their tech site will testify.

As for home users - use an Apple folks, it's simple to use, doesn't go wrong, has nix levels of security. It delivers, and doesn't take. Oh and did I mention it's gorgeous? ;-)

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/112/16666#16666
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-03
Darkphyber
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-03
iDENTiTY
One Patch to Rule Them All 2002-10-04
Anonymous
He should have called this article "Flame Bait"... 2002-10-09
Anonymouse (1 replies)
"Flame Bait" 2002-10-09
Anonymous







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus