Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison
Mark Rasch, 2004-04-12

When a New Hampshire judge threw out chat-log evidence against an accused pedophile, he illustrated just how jumbled and confused Internet privacy law can be.

Comments Mode:
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-12
Anonymous (2 replies)
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-13
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-15
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-12
Anonymous (1 replies)
Copyright infringement in RAM 2004-04-14
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-12
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-13
Anonymous (1 replies)
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-14
bee-keeper
lawful interception? 2004-04-13
Anonymous (1 replies)
lawful interception? 2004-04-13
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-13
Anonymous (2 replies)
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-14
Anon E Mouse
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-15
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-13
Anonymous Joe
Need Guidance for Whose on First 2004-04-14
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-14
Ric Werme
and don't forget Trillian 2004-04-14
Anonymous
Pretty flimsy law... 2004-04-14
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-15
Roy Sullivan <lasheray@msn.com>
Dura lex, sed lex 2004-04-15
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-15
Anonymous
I am not sure about the specific instant messenger programs quoted in the article, but generally don't all IM arguably record the conversation?

There is a chat window, it has a complete record of the entire conversation, and when you close that window you choose to discard that recording. I don't see how it is illegal for someone else to NOT discard a recording.

Now if no record of the conversation was made during the conversation, then fair enough, but an IM client that has a chat window, by default, records the conversation.

In my opinion it is obvious that your computer is recording the conversation, hence you are consenting to the record if you use the program. Moreover, if your computer is recording the conversation so is the computer of the person/police officer you are talking too, so use of the program is consenting it to the conversation being recorded. The fact that you close the program down and CHOOSE to discard the recording is irrelvant imo.

But hell, I'm no lawyer.

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/233/25807#25807
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-16
errtu
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2004-04-16
Anonymous
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2006-04-03
Firegirl
Chat, Copy, Paste, Prison 2006-04-28
Anonymous







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus