Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Vista
Practical Certifications
Don Parker, 2005-03-28

Recent changes to the GIAC makes one question the value of certification for the security industry.

Comments Mode:
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Alex Arndt (1 replies)
Practically Certified 2005-03-30
Carlos Canoto
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Mestafio
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Anonymous (4 replies)
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Gene Cronk
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Walter
Practically Certified 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Cool Names != quality 2005-03-29
Bipin Gautam <visitbipin[]hotmail.com> (2 replies)

I have vividly heard Mr.'X' got to their 'local test center' with the name of Mr.'Y' and take the EXAM. Mr.'Y' pays Mr.'X' for his job..... and no doubt Mr.'Y' is certified even without turning a page. That's what I call PROSTITUTION OF KNOWLEDGE. There is no further questions asked or verification done to assure Mr.'X' is the real Mr.'X' who is taking the exam for HIMSELF not with a false name.

Moreover, I'd love to call.... RHCE == R.H.C.Amature

RHCE curriculum is very incomplete! ---the curriculum assumes, you to be a RH newbie who knows nothing about the architecture and is designed to cover from the very(possible) basics. This occupies half of the curriculum. And when they should be focusing more to create good standards(in the Network Services & Security Administration part...) the certification JUST* demands VERY basic overall knowledge about Network Services (Apache, Squid, DNS etc...) It barely covers the part for good implementation, deploying solutions & tackling problems in in the real* world. Moreover... the last part, Security Administration is also 50% very newbie*.

But to my surprise, I was stunned to see... some well respected site had its skill level rating as High. while MCSE as average. Is it like, knowing to administrator a server via console a makes you more geeky?

...back then, when I spoke to a group of fresh RHCE holders(All of them already CCNA before RHCE) ...more than half of them knew NOTHING about patch management & for some that wasn't in their priority list. The only one who kinda cared were people who were already working on some business for few years & that's reality.

The current trend in my part of the globe is: getting certifications for MCSE, CCNA, RHCE is a fashion among CS students & most of them have work experience ZERO. So no wonder, the companies will most-likely certify more book worms THAN professionals.

-bipin

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/311/31202#31202
Cool Names != quality 2005-03-30
IAMCanadian (1 replies)
Cool Names != quality 2005-04-05
X
Cool Names != quality 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Jim Moore (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
John H. Sawyer (5 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Don Parker
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-30
Anonymous (2 replies)
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-31
Guy L. Pace, CISSP
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
DanM
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Paul
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Kenton (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Edgar Danielyan CISSP ISSAP ISSMP CISA MBCS (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Re: CISSP 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Brian Almond CISSP, CCSP
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Ron Ropp
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-01
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-01
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-02
Allen
Practical Certifications 2005-04-03
Anonymous
Don't forget about the way it's done: Internet 2005-04-04
Alexandre de Abreu Teixeira
Practical Certifications 2005-04-04
Sherman Hand
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
sebastan
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Kelly (2 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Anonymous
Practicals cannot stay 2005-04-06
Edward Luck, GCFW, ex. SANS instructor (1 replies)
Practicals cannot stay 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
Slade (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-07
Edward Luck (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-07
Don Parker
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Keith
Worthless Certifications compared to College 2005-04-08
Anonymous, NCN (No-Certs-Needed) (2 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: Practical Certifications 2006-06-15
Anonymous, CISSP, GSEC
Re: Practical Certifications 2007-07-28
The Real Ben
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Disappointed
Practical Certifications 2005-07-13
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2007-05-03
DNS Admin







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2008, SecurityFocus