Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Vista
Practical Certifications
Don Parker, 2005-03-28

Recent changes to the GIAC makes one question the value of certification for the security industry.

Comments Mode:
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Alex Arndt (1 replies)
Practically Certified 2005-03-30
Carlos Canoto
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Mestafio
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Anonymous (4 replies)
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Gene Cronk
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Walter
Practically Certified 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Cool Names != quality 2005-03-29
Bipin Gautam <visitbipin[]hotmail.com> (2 replies)
Cool Names != quality 2005-03-30
IAMCanadian (1 replies)
Cool Names != quality 2005-04-05
X
Cool Names != quality 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Jim Moore (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
John H. Sawyer (5 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Don Parker
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-30
Anonymous (2 replies)
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-31
Guy L. Pace, CISSP
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
DanM
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Anonymous
The first cert I ever got was Network + after being in the field for a year. I followed that with CCNA and was impressed at how you had to actually know your stuff to pass.

On the urging of my company, I went through the MCSE classes which seemed more focused on teaching how to take the test rather than teaching how to do the work. I wound up taking electives in two areas I didn't even take classes on. But with that MCSE Paper on my wall, my company was happy. I thought that either I was getting better at my job or the qualifications to pass had gone way down.

They finally sent me to SANS CDI east 2004 where I took the GSEC track and my favorite part was writing the practical. It restored my faith in ability based certification. Of all the certifications I have done, I am most proud of the practical I wrote. Now I am with a new company and am looking at continuing my training. With my CCNA set to expire soon, I had my choices narrowed down to GCWN and CCSP.

I was leaning towards GCWN because I was looking forward to the challenge of the practical. If it's just an "answer the questions" proposition, I might as well take the CCSP. Once I pass one of those, I re-up my CCNA automatically.

Thanks for making the choice easier GIAC. See you next year. Maybe. CISSP...

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/311/31212#31212
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Paul
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Kenton (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Edgar Danielyan CISSP ISSAP ISSMP CISA MBCS (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Re: CISSP 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Brian Almond CISSP, CCSP
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Ron Ropp
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-01
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-01
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-02
Allen
Practical Certifications 2005-04-03
Anonymous
Don't forget about the way it's done: Internet 2005-04-04
Alexandre de Abreu Teixeira
Practical Certifications 2005-04-04
Sherman Hand
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
sebastan
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Kelly (2 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Anonymous
Practicals cannot stay 2005-04-06
Edward Luck, GCFW, ex. SANS instructor (1 replies)
Practicals cannot stay 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
Slade (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-07
Edward Luck (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-07
Don Parker
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Keith
Worthless Certifications compared to College 2005-04-08
Anonymous, NCN (No-Certs-Needed) (2 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: Practical Certifications 2006-06-15
Anonymous, CISSP, GSEC
Re: Practical Certifications 2007-07-28
The Real Ben
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Disappointed
Practical Certifications 2005-07-13
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2007-05-03
DNS Admin







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2008, SecurityFocus