Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Vista
Practical Certifications
Don Parker, 2005-03-28

Recent changes to the GIAC makes one question the value of certification for the security industry.

Comments Mode:
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Alex Arndt (1 replies)
Practically Certified 2005-03-30
Carlos Canoto
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Mestafio
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Anonymous (4 replies)
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Gene Cronk
Practically Certified 2005-03-29
Walter
Practically Certified 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Cool Names != quality 2005-03-29
Bipin Gautam <visitbipin[]hotmail.com> (2 replies)
Cool Names != quality 2005-03-30
IAMCanadian (1 replies)
Cool Names != quality 2005-04-05
X
Cool Names != quality 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Jim Moore (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
John H. Sawyer (5 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Don Parker
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-30
Anonymous (2 replies)
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-31
Guy L. Pace, CISSP
Boot Camps\SANS Needs to Change 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
DanM
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Paul
Practical Certifications 2005-03-29
Kenton (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Edgar Danielyan CISSP ISSAP ISSMP CISA MBCS (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Re: CISSP 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Re: the CISSP

I thought it good to note that this certification is really of most practical value for management level folks, rather than hands on level technical people. I've run into too many CISSPs that are remarkably ignorant about technical issues, and couldn't even install an network driver on their own, much less install an operating system or configure a firewall.

But for a management level person, it actually is a good cert to get them ready to have a grasp of the terminology used in the industry, and a high level understanding of how various technologies work. It also doesn't hurt that a lot of employers/contracts are demanding this cert now.

It is disappointing about the GIAC certs though. I had an interest in pursuing other GIAC certs beyond the Security Essentials cert I already have, but will have to reconsider the cost vs. value question now.

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/311/31229#31229
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Brian Almond CISSP, CCSP
Practical Certifications 2005-03-30
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Ron Ropp
Practical Certifications 2005-03-31
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-01
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-01
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-02
Allen
Practical Certifications 2005-04-03
Anonymous
Don't forget about the way it's done: Internet 2005-04-04
Alexandre de Abreu Teixeira
Practical Certifications 2005-04-04
Sherman Hand
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
sebastan
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-05
Kelly (2 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Anonymous
Practicals cannot stay 2005-04-06
Edward Luck, GCFW, ex. SANS instructor (1 replies)
Practicals cannot stay 2005-04-06
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2005-04-06
Slade (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-07
Edward Luck (1 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-07
Don Parker
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Keith
Worthless Certifications compared to College 2005-04-08
Anonymous, NCN (No-Certs-Needed) (2 replies)
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: Practical Certifications 2006-06-15
Anonymous, CISSP, GSEC
Re: Practical Certifications 2007-07-28
The Real Ben
Practical Certifications 2005-04-08
Disappointed
Practical Certifications 2005-07-13
Anonymous
Practical Certifications 2007-05-03
DNS Admin







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2008, SecurityFocus