Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Vista
Sony's legal issues
Mark Rasch, 2005-11-14

Last month I wrote about a dispute between the Federal Trade Commission and a spyware distributor where the FTC alleged that an End User License Agreement, which essentially told downloaders that they were downloading spyware, was a false and deceptive trade practice. Two events cause me to revisit this issue. First, the FTC has gone after another spyware distributor, and second, Sony Corporation has caused the surreptitious installation of a rootkit-type program to enforce its digital rights management on its music CDs, claiming authority to do so under an End User License Agreement.

Comments Mode:
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-14
fatman (2 replies)
Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-15
Mark D. Rasch (2 replies)
Re: Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-17
Anonymous
Re: Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-17
Yvan Boily
Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-22
R Simard
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-15
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
Anonymous
Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-17
Anonymous
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-15
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
Anonymous
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
norgan
The problems is that we are now putting doubt in legitimate users minds, that means they may seek the already ripped versions from the net rather than go and buy a cd that may, for all intensive purposes, damage your computer, or at least the inner workings of your operating system.
DRM is great for the artists, I myself play with composing music at home and if I were to release a track I would like to feel that my music is protected so that only I may change it or reproduce it in any way. I would still however want my listeners to be able to store it on any device, including a computer, to listen to at leisure. I mean that's what I made the music for right?
I'd be interested to hear from actual artists on this and see what they think of what the record companies are doing to their music.
Sony and other music publishers, and software publishers for that matter, or basically any IP(intellectual property) supplier, are completely entitled to try and stop illegal copyrighting practises but they must think them through and prove them in the real world first, just as all major software developers do now. You cannot just simply distribute software (in Sony's case by someone who didn't even know about driver coding, you can see on sysinternals website that there are links to initial queries by this programmer about how to do this.
Bottom line is we need to firm up these technologies and the accompanying legislation as this becomes a more and more real life problem. There are many things in the digital world that are now making huge in-roads into main stream commercial products and our lives.


[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/369/32661#32661
Here's how you get the CD to play... 2005-11-16
Gordon Fecyk
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
dreq
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
Alexey Vesnin
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
ChiRaven
May be illegal in UK 2005-11-16
Anonymous
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
Steve (1 replies)
Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-11-19
Mark Rasch (1 replies)
Re: Re: Sony's legal issues 2005-12-01
Anonymous
Sony's legal issues - EULA and DELL 2005-11-16
Anonymous (1 replies)
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-16
Steve
But what are the consumer's remedies? 2005-11-17
HavaCuppaJoe (2 replies)
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-21
Anonymous
You Missed Something Big! 2005-11-22
Anonymous
Validity of the EULA 2005-11-22
Stephan Schulz
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-22
JCD
What recourse does a buyer have? 2005-11-22
Jaywalk (1 replies)
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-22
Capt Chas
Sony's legal issues 2005-11-29
Thaddy de Koning







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2008, SecurityFocus