Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Vista
The big DRM mistake
Scott Granneman, 2006-03-01

Digital Rights Managements hurts paying customers, destroys Fair Use rights, renders customers' investments worthless, and can always be defeated. Why are consumers and publishers being forced to use DRM?

Comments Mode:
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-01
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-03
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-06
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Re: Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-13
Prabhat Sharma
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-01
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Anonymous
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Re: Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-03
Anonymous
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-10-31
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-01
Tom Arnold (1 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Julian Bond (1 replies)
Re: Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-03
Tom Arnold
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-01
PCS Consulting
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-01
John (2 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Anonymous
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Tim Donahue
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Harrold
When you buy copyrighted material, you are BUYING IT, not licencing it 2006-03-02
Anonymous (4 replies)
Re: When you buy copyrighted material, you are BUYING IT, not licencing it 2006-03-02
Mister Jalopy (2 replies)
Re: Re: When you buy copyrighted material, you are BUYING IT, not licencing it 2006-03-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
The original poster was referring to the law: it is quite clear that when you buy a CD or a book you own it outright, you are not licensing the content as they would like. (See wikipedia Fair Use page for legal info). So the author is wrong about this. The EULA will only be valid if a court holds that he entered into a contract prior to purchase (unlikely IMO). Otherwise, the law says he owns the content, and can do what he likes with it, apart from redistributing it. Among other things he can sell it. The only caveat is that he can't circumvent the DRM due to the DMCA.
Emil

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/390/33225#33225
The good news and the bad news. 2006-03-02
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Matt UK
It's even worse than you thought 2006-03-02
Eric M. Berg (1 replies)
No DRM: Magnatune 2006-03-02
Adam Blinkinsop (1 replies)
Re: No DRM: Magnatune 2006-04-11
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-04
OK Mores
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-02
O K Mores (2 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-08
Anonymous
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-04-13
Anonymous
How do you protect your content ?? 2006-03-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
Fighting the wrong war 2006-03-03
Frank Csorba (1 replies)
Re: Fighting the wrong war 2006-03-08
Anonymous
Return It 2006-03-03
Josh
iTunesU has no DRM 2006-03-03
Otto
It wont stop there 2006-03-03
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-03
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-03
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-03
Anonymous
Not Disagreeing With You ... 2006-03-04
Anonymous
For God sake, just type it 2006-03-04
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-05
bl0rf (1 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-08
Igor M
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-05
Peej
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-06
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-08
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-08
Anonymous
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-03-10
Anonymous
Apple's big DRM mistake 2006-03-08
Anonymous
AAC is "crappy" ? 2006-03-14
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2006-03-17
Paul
The big DRM mistake 2006-05-13
yes, new yorker can be copied to hard drive. see this. (1 replies)
Re: The big DRM mistake 2006-05-16
Anonymous
The real secret of DRM 2006-11-04
Follow the Money
The big DRM mistake 2006-12-02
Anonymous fool
The big DRM mistake 2006-12-02
Anonymous
The big DRM mistake 2007-01-29
The View from Downunder







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2007, SecurityFocus