Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
The value of vulnerabilities
Jason Miller, 2006-03-07

There is value in finding vulnerabilities. Yet many people believe that a vulnerability doesn't exist until it is disclosed to the public. We know that vulnerabilities need to be disclosed, but what role do vendors have to make these issues public?

Comments Mode:
The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-07
Anonymous (4 replies)
Re: The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-08
infamous41md
Re: The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-08
Anonymous
Re: The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-08
Dancho Danchev
Re: The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-17
Anonymous
The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-08
Matthew Murphy (1 replies)
Re: The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-13
John Smith
The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-08
Anonymous (1 replies)
The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-08
Omar A. Herrera (2 replies)
Re:Good Points 2006-03-08
R_U_Trustified (2 replies)
Re: Re:Good Points 2006-03-09
infamous41md
Re: Re:Good Points 2006-03-09
Matthew Murphy (1 replies)
Re: Re: Re:Good Points 2006-03-14
Robert E. Lee (1 replies)
Re: Re: Re: Re:Good Points 2006-03-15
Matthew Murphy (1 replies)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:Good Points 2006-03-17
Anonymous
The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-10
Max (1 replies)
Re: The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-14
Robert E. Lee
Responsible disclosure 2006-03-13
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Responsible disclosure 2006-03-14
Robert E. Lee
> I'd submit that to be truly a responsible disclosure, no vulnerability should be released to the entire public without a workaround included.

Sometimes the only workaround is to disable public access to the service or software that is vulnerable. According to our customers of third-party products, that is a better option than operating blindly unaware of the vulnerability.

They believe that vulnerability information should flow freely directly from the researcher to the end users without delay. It's ok to share the information with the vendor of the software at the same time as notifying the end-users, but remember it's up to the end user to make changes, and they can't do that without the proper information.

Too many people make the mistake of assuming that the researcher is the first or only one to find the vulnerability. Waiting for vendor approved workarounds before public disclosure of vulnerabilities makes everyone more at risk.

Robert E. Lee
Dyad Security

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/391/33312#33312
The value of vulnerabilities 2006-03-16
C. Winchester
What Value? 2006-03-17
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: What Value? 2006-03-20
infamous41md
Re: What Value? 2006-03-28
Anonymous







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus