Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Time for a new certification
Don Parker, 2007-05-01

I wrote a column for Securityfocus some time ago that aired my concerns over GIAC dropping the practical portion of their certification process. That column resulted in a lot of feedback, with most agreeing about how GIAC bungled what was up till then, the best certification around.

Comments Mode:
Time for a new certification 2007-05-01
Steven Adair
Time for a new certification 2007-05-01
Wim Remes (2 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-09
Anonymous
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-20
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Omar Herrera
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Fatman
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous
Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-02
Richard Bejtlich (1 replies)
Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-02
Don Parker (1 replies)
Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-03
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-03
Don Parker
Re: Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-04
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-22
Raman (1 replies)
Blocking port 53 TCP vs CISSP 2007-05-24
G Bickers
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Ron Black
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-07
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Rob Shein (1 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Don Parker (1 replies)
Time for a new certification 2007-05-03
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-06
Don Parker
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-08
Anonymous
Bring it on! 2007-05-03
ichinin (2 replies)
Re: Bring it on! 2007-05-06
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Re: Bring it on! 2007-05-15
Anonymous
Re: Bring it on! 2007-05-07
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-08
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-09
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-10
Anonymous
Doesn't GIAC already have a "pen-test" focused certification? I thought that is what their GHTQ certification was for, why do they need another one?

While I agree with many of your points regarding the practical exam I do not believe another cert is the answer. Look at jobs postings and I think you will see why GIAC watered down their requirements. There are way more postings for CISSP's (requires a test and no practical) than GIAC certified positions. Why would I go through all the hassel of a GIAC cert when I can get a CISSP and have a 10-1 ratio of job opportunities.

It is just like you stated, HR and employers do not know the difference between a gold & silver GIAC standard and I would wager many do not know the difference between a cissp and giac cert, if they have even heard of a GIAC cert.

"Time for a better Marketing Campaign" might be a better title for your story



[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/443/34535#34535
Time for a new certification 2007-05-11
Anonymous
The CEPT & CPTE 2007-05-16
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-20
CISSP guy (1 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-25
DeMartian
Time for a new certification 2007-05-24
CISA, CISSP, GSEC, CEH, MCSE, CCNA, CCSA, SEC+ Guy







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus