Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Time for a new certification
Don Parker, 2007-05-01

I wrote a column for Securityfocus some time ago that aired my concerns over GIAC dropping the practical portion of their certification process. That column resulted in a lot of feedback, with most agreeing about how GIAC bungled what was up till then, the best certification around.

Comments Mode:
Time for a new certification 2007-05-01
Steven Adair
Time for a new certification 2007-05-01
Wim Remes (2 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-09
Anonymous
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-20
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Omar Herrera
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Fatman
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous
Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-02
Richard Bejtlich (1 replies)
Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-02
Don Parker (1 replies)
Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-03
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-03
Don Parker
Re: Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-04
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Blocking port 53 TCP 2007-05-22
Raman (1 replies)
Blocking port 53 TCP vs CISSP 2007-05-24
G Bickers
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Ron Black
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-07
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Rob Shein (1 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-02
Don Parker (1 replies)
Time for a new certification 2007-05-03
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-06
Don Parker
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-08
Anonymous
Bring it on! 2007-05-03
ichinin (2 replies)
Re: Bring it on! 2007-05-06
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Re: Bring it on! 2007-05-15
Anonymous
Re: Bring it on! 2007-05-07
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-08
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-09
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-10
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-11
Anonymous
The CEPT & CPTE 2007-05-16
Anonymous
Time for a new certification 2007-05-20
CISSP guy (1 replies)
Re: Time for a new certification 2007-05-25
DeMartian
While in reality, HR sees CISSP certs as the favorable certification because most HR departments scan based on non-IT information, the CISSP certification is really EASY!

Easy I say because I work more than 60 hours a week, have a family and don't have much time to study anything. The CISSP was a breeze to pass, I think the CCNP is even tougher to pass than the CISSP.

I would personally put a LOT more stock in the GIAC certifications. IT staff needs to communicate to their HR staff just exactly which certifications are key and that above ALL else, true experience beats any certification hands down.

Once you are in the security field, who has the time to even schedule a test let alone study for one?

How about a database of individuals, who check in and take updated little tests here and there and maintain an ever evolving score based on their experience, education credits, papers written, recommendations, tests taken, all combined together to come up with a score between 1 and 1000 to rate their level of expertise?

Any certification that can be passed after taking a 2-week long boot camp has no real merit.

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/443/34568#34568
Time for a new certification 2007-05-24
CISA, CISSP, GSEC, CEH, MCSE, CCNA, CCSA, SEC+ Guy







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus