Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Vista
E-mail privacy to disappear?
Mark Rasch, 2007-11-02

On October 8, 2007, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in Cincinnati granted the government's request for a full-panel hearing in United States v. Warshak case centering on the right of privacy for stored electronic communications. At issue is whether the procedure whereby the government can subpoena stored copies of your e-mail -- similar to the way they could simply subpoena any physical mail sitting on your desk -- is unconstitutionally broad.

Comments Mode:
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-02
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-02
Anonymous (1 replies)
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-04
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-05
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-05
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-07
Mark D. Rasch
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-06
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: E-mail privacy to disappear? 2008-02-16
beenthere
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-07
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-08
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-09
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-10
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-14
Anonymous
State Statutes Allowing For Privacy Communicated by Electronic Means 2007-11-15
Jason
Great Article! I am doing a little research on a related topic and your post sparked my interest. I was reading a case this evening (Scott v. Beth Israel Med. Ctr., 2007 WL 3053351 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 2007)) where the court noted two statutory provisions which essentially state that you don't waive your right to privacy simply by communicating electronically. The statutes are McKinley's CPLR 4548 (NY) and Cal. Evid. Code § 917(b). (CA)

The court ultimately found that the plaintiff waived his right to privacy because he sent the emails from his work email address and his company had an email policy which explicitly said you do not have the right to privacy. Is there a difference between a company's email policy and the Terms and Conditions of a Private ISP? Should there be? Are the interests and objectives behind each the same? If there is not a difference between the two, then what is the purpose of having the state statutes which protect our communications?

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/456/34800#34800
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2007-11-21
Anonymous
E-mail privacy to disappear? 2008-03-19
sageb1







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2008, SecurityFocus