Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Blaming the Good Samaritan
Houston Carr, 2008-09-26

In the early 90's, I attended an academic conference in Hawaii. At one presentation, a colleague from the University of California at Berkeley whom I'll refer to as "the supervisor," told a story of young hackers, who he referred to as the Urchins.

Comments Mode:
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-26
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-14
The Better Samaritan
disagree with premise 2008-09-27
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: disagree with premise 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Re: disagree with premise 2008-10-04
Anonymous
Re: disagree with premise 2008-10-10
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-27
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-28
RU_Trustified
Where to draw the line 2008-09-29
Daniel Thomas (1 replies)
Re: Where to draw the line 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-29
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Darin (4 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Anonymous
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
RU_Trustified (2 replies)
Re: Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-03
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Brandon (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Teknohazard
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Mr. Mike (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
R... (1 replies)
Thin Skull Rule 2008-10-17
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan - You Idiots 2008-10-01
Bill (2 replies)
Many offer an analogy - suppose a stranger broke into your house (or similar) and left a helpful note. blah blah.

This is a logical fallacy called 'straw man' argument.

Let me give you a better analogy:

A son living at home, figures out how to enter without damage, and leaves a helpful note for Dad.

This is better, but far from perfet becuase i've failed to take account of the 'duty of care' or contractual issues when a student pays for a service, he should expect a secure one to safeguard his personal details and work.

Context matters, don't just focus on a perverted from of a principle.

So to all those who offered a logical fallacy I say to you - you're an idiot.

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/481/35175#35175
Blaming the "Cracker" 2008-10-11
Anonymous
Time to grow up 2008-10-11
Anonymous
Tresspassing 2008-10-28
Jake Brodsky







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus