Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Blaming the Good Samaritan
Houston Carr, 2008-09-26

In the early 90's, I attended an academic conference in Hawaii. At one presentation, a colleague from the University of California at Berkeley whom I'll refer to as "the supervisor," told a story of young hackers, who he referred to as the Urchins.

Comments Mode:
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-26
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-02
Anonymous
You've missed the entire point which is ironic given your remark about objectivism.

The only way to objectively determine someone's intent is based upon their actions, which is a crude method at best.

If they do something overt and incontrovertably malicious, then you have good cause to judge their intentions as bad.

But lack of overt and incontrovertably malicious acts does not mean their intentions were good. In such a case all you have is their word.

So basically, unless you can prove they were doing something bad, you only have their word to judge what their intentions were.

Do you really think it is wise to base the legality of an action on the word of the person who would suffer if deemed illegal?

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/481/35190#35190
Re: Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-14
The Better Samaritan
disagree with premise 2008-09-27
Anonymous (3 replies)
Re: disagree with premise 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Re: disagree with premise 2008-10-04
Anonymous
Re: disagree with premise 2008-10-10
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-27
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-28
RU_Trustified
Where to draw the line 2008-09-29
Daniel Thomas (1 replies)
Re: Where to draw the line 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-29
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous (2 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Darin (4 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Anonymous
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
RU_Trustified (2 replies)
Re: Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Anonymous
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-03
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Anonymous
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Brandon (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
Teknohazard
Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-09-30
Mr. Mike (1 replies)
Re: Blaming the Good Samaritan 2008-10-01
R... (1 replies)
Thin Skull Rule 2008-10-17
Anonymous
Blaming the "Cracker" 2008-10-11
Anonymous
Time to grow up 2008-10-11
Anonymous
Tresspassing 2008-10-28
Jake Brodsky







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus