For these guest vendor columnists, could we please make a sub under the headline that says "Guest industry columnist" or something like that? Or perhaps make the by line say, in this case, "Tim Callan, Verisign"
I had a really bad taste in my mouth from that article. I believed going in that Mr. Callan was reporting without bias, while his article clearly is written from Versign's position. It is not inherently bad to have an article written from Verisign's perspective, but it should be clearly noted at the beginning so that the reader doesn't begin to distrust the writer.

Once I realized at the end of the piece that it was written by Verisign, I blew off the piece almost entirely. Had I know it upfront, I still wouldn't give it the same weight as a well thought out counterpoint to a dedicated researcher's work, but I wouldn't have dismissed it so easily.

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/488/35306#35306