Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers
Richard Forno, 2002-03-28

The Good Samaritan defence, invoked by hackers like Adrian Lamo, can too easily be distorted by those with less altruistic intentions.

Comments Mode:
Good Samaritan Guidelines 2002-03-29
Anonymous (1 replies)
Good Samaritan Guidelines 2002-04-09
ImNotAHacker@hotmail.com
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-29
Anonymous (1 replies)
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-01
Steve (2 replies)
The responsible netizen can try to get the contact information of someone who can close that hole, and let them know about it. If they ignore that, the responsible netizen can then inform securityfocus.com, the BBB, or other relevant organization, and if the company is STILL not closing the security hole, the responsible netizen will alert the media (after first switching to a different bank).

And no, happening across an unprotected URL that link browsing wouldn't hit isn't hacking any more than making a U-turn in someone's driveway is trespassing. It's the pulling into the driveway, getting out, and rattling doorknobs and checking windowsills that I'd consider trespassing, and it's using misconfigured public web pages and proxy servers for access to internal networks that I'd consider hacking.
-Steve

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/70/11537#11537
The first four letters of analogy. . . . 2002-04-01
Ira Wing (2 replies)
The first four letters of analogy. . . . 2002-04-04
Andy Richmond (1 replies)
We're both right. 2002-04-13
Ira Wing
Case Against 2002-04-02
Spade
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-03
Andy Schmitt (kphrakNO@worldofschmittSPAM.ALLOWEDcom) (1 replies)
"...Good Samaritan Hackers" Bad English. 2002-04-05
Andy Richmond (1 replies)
right.. 2002-04-09
Anonymous
Which law? 2002-04-04
80N
What about the "lurkers"? 2002-04-12
Bob Radvanovsky
Digital Vigilantism? 2002-04-12
Bob Radvanovsky







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus