Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers
Richard Forno, 2002-03-28

The Good Samaritan defence, invoked by hackers like Adrian Lamo, can too easily be distorted by those with less altruistic intentions.

Comments Mode:
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-28
Anonymous (1 replies)
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-03
Anonymous (1 replies)
All,
I can't agree. I am a Security Engineer for an Atlanta-based security firm, and have done many, many pen. tests, audits, and network security runs. I have to say that if I went about and did some 'good samaritan hacking' on my own, I'd consider myself on the wrong side of the law. The analogy of someone walking through my house is a valid one. I wouldn't want anyone rummaging through my network, or those I protect, and if something like that happens that person(s) is/are considered to be illegal intruders - no matter how 'good' their intentions are. If you want to learn how to hack, set up a baby network for yourself at home, if you want to go to jail, come knock on one of the virtual doors I protect - I'll make sure you do jail time.

...sekuritywizard@hushmail.com

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/70/11609#11609
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-07
johnny
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-28
Anonymous (8 replies)
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-29
Rick Forno (1 replies)
It's really refreshing... 2002-04-17
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-29
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-01
Matthew Z.
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-02
Jordan
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-02
Somebody
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-07
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-07
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-17
Not-Anonymous
so next time i mistype an url... 2002-03-29
Anonymous (3 replies)
so next time i mistype an url... 2002-03-30
Anonymous (1 replies)
so next time i mistype an url... 2002-04-03
Anonymous
so next time i mistype an url... 2002-04-07
johnny
If you stumble across a security hole, don't report it -- you're incriminating yourself. 2002-04-17
Anonymous
Good Samaritan Guidelines 2002-03-29
Anonymous (1 replies)
Good Samaritan Guidelines 2002-04-09
ImNotAHacker@hotmail.com
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-29
In Response to the Anonymous Above
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-29
Anonymous (1 replies)
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-01
Steve (2 replies)
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-03
Anonymous
You're opening yourself up to prosecution if you fess up. 2002-04-17
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-29
Steve
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-03-29
Me (1 replies)
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-01
Scott Runnels
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-01
William W. Bishop
The question is simple, but the answer may be complicated, and becoming more so. 2002-04-01
Anonymous
The first four letters of analogy. . . . 2002-04-01
Ira Wing (2 replies)
The first four letters of analogy. . . .whaaaat? 2002-04-04
Rick Forno (1 replies)
The first four letters of analogy. . . .whaaaat? 2002-04-17
Anonymous
The first four letters of analogy. . . . 2002-04-04
Andy Richmond (1 replies)
We're both right. 2002-04-13
Ira Wing
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-02
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-02
M A Nelms
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-02
Anonymous
Case Against 2002-04-02
Spade
The Mentality and Psychology behind the White Hat 2002-04-03
Alec (1 replies)
The Mentality and Psychology behind the White Hat 2002-04-04
lb
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-03
Andy Schmitt (kphrakNO@worldofschmittSPAM.ALLOWEDcom) (1 replies)
"...Good Samaritan Hackers" Bad English. 2002-04-05
Andy Richmond (1 replies)
right.. 2002-04-09
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-04
Anonymous
Which law? 2002-04-04
80N
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-04
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-04
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-05
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-08
Anonymous (1 replies)
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-09
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-10
Anonymous (1 replies)
NOT Accidental 2002-04-14
Anonymous
What about the "lurkers"? 2002-04-12
Bob Radvanovsky
Digital Vigilantism? 2002-04-12
Bob Radvanovsky
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-13
Anonymous
Beware the Kindness of Strangers: The Case Against Good Samaritan Hackers 2002-04-14
gil@ateliermobile.de
Some Good Samaritan Hackers' Arguments Like Voyeurs' Defenses 2002-04-16
J.D. Abolins







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus