Search: Home Bugtraq Vulnerabilities Mailing Lists Jobs Tools Beta Programs
The Right to Defend
Tim Mullen, 2002-07-29

Is it criminal to reach out and hack an infected machine that's attacking your network?

Comments Mode:
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous (10 replies)
If somebody breaks into your house, do you start your own investigation and hunt him down, or do you call the police?

If someone's car is repeatedly blocking access to your garage, do you tow it away yourself or do you call the police?

What you are calling for is wild West. Theses times are over. Prosecution and law enforcement have to be in the hands of the government. This is one of the characteristics of a civilized state. And this applies to the real world and cyberspace as well.

And no, I don't have a solution for the problem you are talking of. It took a long time until we reached our current state of order in the real world. Why should we give up this achievement now in cyberspace?

[ reply ]

Link to this comment: http://www.securityfocus.com/comments/columns/98/15875#15875
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous (1 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-08-01
Anonymous (3 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-08-01
Anonymous (1 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-08-05
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-08-06
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-08-07
moleculem@t
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous (1 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-31
Kruse (1 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-08-01
Anonimouse
The Right to Defend 2002-07-31
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-31
William Stone, III
The Right to Defend 2002-08-01
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-08-05
Anonymous
this makes no sense 2002-08-07
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-08-08
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous
Happened with Code Red 2... 2002-07-29
Nicholas Weaver
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Matthew Waddell (3 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-31
J. J. Horner (1 replies)
More Misinformation 2002-08-07
Anonymous 3 Letter Agency
Misinformation 2002-08-07
Anonymous 3 Letter Agency
Wanna be a cowboy 2002-07-29
Me (2 replies)
Wanna be a cowboy 2002-07-30
Anonymous
Wanna be a cowboy 2002-07-31
Anonymous
Responisbility for abetting a crime 2002-07-29
Anonymous (2 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-29
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Anonymous
The Bigger Picture 2002-07-30
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Anonymous (1 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Mel
The Right to Defend 2002-07-30
Hamster1
The Right to Defend 2002-07-31
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-08-01
Anonymous
The Right to Defend 2002-08-03
sceptic
The Right to Defend 2002-08-04
Itdincor
The Right to Defend 2002-08-05
State Admin (1 replies)
The Right to Defend 2002-08-06
Anonymous sysadmin
Here here! 2002-08-06
Anonymous (1 replies)
Here here! 2002-08-06
Astrix
The Right to Defend 2002-08-08
IV







 

Privacy Statement
Copyright 2009, SecurityFocus